Wednesday, February 29, 2012

Post-MRI diagnosis

Last Thursday I met with David Johnson, a sports medicine orthopedist who works out of Washington Hospital on Irving St. and the Foxhall Medical Building on New Mexico. He looked at my X-Ray, saw nothing wrong, and I recounted to him the last couple months as it relates to my knee. He agreed that there was likely some issue since PT hasn't helped and it may only be visible on an MRI. He prescribed the MRI and identified regional MRI offices that have newer machines and shorter waits. In addition, he said I could try a specific PT exercise to try and help my knee.

  • While sitting in a chair, cross my left leg over my right and let it lay there. Extend my right leg and hold it out to strengthen the quad muscles and increase bloodflow to the knee.
Ultimately, I was able to schedule an MRI at Foxhall MRI in NW for the following day (Friday). An MRI works by introducing intense magnetic fields that cause the nuclei in that part of the body to create their own magnetic fields that are then detectable by the scanner. The machine will take "slices" of the body part to get more highly-detailed images and can view the body part from numerous angles and axis.

I went in and relatively quickly got situated. The technician emphasized the need to stay still during each of the sessions in order to reduce the potential for blurred images.  I had at least five series taken that were 3, 3, 5, 5.5, and 3.5 minutes in duration. I had to focus on my breathing to ensure my leg wouldn't move. Sometimes, it takes a mandate to not move your leg in order to believe that restless leg syndrome might actually be a thing. In any event, they handled the images and I requested a separate CD to keep as an electronic copy. The following are the applicable images followed by highlights of the injured area.
Although Dr. Johnson couldn't get me in the same day, I was able to schedule the follow-up for Monday. After waiting 45 minutes, Dr. Johnson arrived and viewed my MRI films. What he noticed was white with a black line on the medial (inside) side of my patella (kneecap) in the series looking up my leg from below. Everything else, MCL, ACL, LCL, etc looked good. He said that the white and black indicates fluid built up in-between the medial ligament and the patella. Typically, this occurs when there is some injury to the knee where the kneecap is pulled from its natural position (for example, a dislocation). Another ortho friend of mine named it as a medialpatellafemoralligament avulsion. Essentially, the ligament was pulled away from the kneecap and the resulting inflammation and gap allowed fluid to build which has been the source of my pain. 

The good news is that there is no surgery. Also, I'm glad that there was an actual culprit as I would have been extremely flustered to go through all this just to find out that nothing was visible on the MRI. Dr. Johnson said it could take 3-4 months from the initial event for the injury to heal which puts me at the end of April and definitely takes me out of Comrades since I won't have a qualifying race and won't have really any miles in training. During the interim, he encouraged me to continue forward-motion activities (swimming, biking, elliptical). In addition, he said I should continue to do the seated leg extensions and can incorporate the occasional use of ice in a cloth but only for 8-10 minutes at a time.

Once any pain is gone, he said I can try to start running again. Very slowly. He provided the following suggested plan (dayweek):
Mon1 - 1/4 mile
Wed1 - 1/4 mile
Fri1 - 1/2 mile
Sun1 - 1/2 mile
Tue2 - 3/4 mile
Thu2 - 3/4 mile
..and continue in that fashion until I get up to two miles per run. At that point, I can increase my mileage by 10% on a weekly basis. For example, in the week where I am able to do 3 2-mile runs (6 miles), the following week I can do 6.6 miles. Obviously, back off if I feel pain and it's a small increase but will more or less amount to exponential growth.

So, in lieu of Comrades and the beginning of my ultramarathon career, I need to identify some races later in the season so I can accumulate an adequate amount of training.

Friday, February 17, 2012

Time for an MRI

Another couple weeks and nothing to show for it. I have had a couple decent runs. Last Friday after visiting Sonya, she taped my knee with some cover roll and lueko tape. The idea is to pull my kneecap inward. Running with it was an improvement but walking more uncomfortable than running. I have since run without taping and it has been about the same so the taping didn't really do much. I was feeling good about things after running Wednesday when pain was minimal but it increased again today while running the 2/3 intervals. Again, the pain/discomfort was worse when walking. While running, I have been able to maintain an aggressive forefoot strike and it has become much more comfortable.

Biking has been less painful although I don't seem to have the same leg strength while working the indoor trainer, i.e. it's been more difficult to maintain 20mph than it was previously. Swimming has gotten better, in large part because I have been kicking from my hip instead of my quads. Also, the strength routine I'm on, including a fair number of pull-ups, seems to have given me a bit stronger stroke. I've also been focusing on maintaining a good body roll through the stroke.

This week Sonya had me add:

  • One-legged ball pick-up squats (one leg at a time, one leg in air behind body, squat down to pick up a ball. Stand up, squat down to replace it on the ground. 20 reps each leg)
  • Lateral hip exercises (theraband at ankles, walk laterally ~20 steps in each direction)
  • Foot arch strengthening activities (with heel, ball and toes on ground, arch foot). These are all intended to work the whole system of me leg.


After more than a month of PT and performing the recommended exercises at home, I would expect that there has been some strengthening of the supposedly guilty muscle groups. This leads me to believe it may be a more serious issue. Therefore, next week I have an appointment to see Dr. David Johnson for a second opinion and hopefully, an MRI. The MRI should provide some additional details regarding cartilage depth that the Xray could not.

I looked into Comrades policy for transfer for a registration. They only allow substitution meaning that somebody wishing to get into the closed race needs to finds somebody that cannot or no longer wishes to do it. I'm thinking I may try and find somewhere to post the bib and perhaps get paid back by the substitute for the effort.

Thursday, February 2, 2012

Stagnation

I've been back to Sonya a couple times and there hasn't been any noticeable improvement in my knee. Sonya suggested that if things are still not improving over the next two weeks that I go back to the orthopedist and get an MRI. That does not bode well.

Yesterday (2/1), she added some new activities to my rehab, these focus on strengthening the knee. In addition to the stretching and side leg lifts I've been doing since I started, she has me doing these:


  • Bosu Ball squats. With Flat part of bosu ball up, legs shoulder-width apart, perform 3x10 squats ensuring that legs are moving in one axis and not tracking inward.
  • Modified Lunge. Get into lunge position and perform lunge ensuring front knee does not extend past front foot and knees do not track inward. 2x20.
  • Step Downs. One-leg step downs front 2x20, each leg, each direction, ensure knees do not move inward.


Also, for years I've felt my left shoulder socket has been off, starting with a church softball game in high school when I over-swang (sp?) and pulled it out of the socket. Sonya gave me the following strength exercises to improve the stabilizer muscles in my shoulder.


  • With back against the wall and elbows touching the wall, forearms out 90 degrees with palms up. Rotate arms outward staying at 90 degrees and touch the wall. 3x10. If that is not a problem, stand with back against wall top of hands touching wall at waist level. Raise hands above head while maintaining contact with the wall. 3x10.
  • Take a ball and extend arm forward, holding ball against the wall and make sure shoulders are square to the wall. Makes circles with palm on ball and rotate 10 times clockwise and 10 times counter-clockwise; repeat 3 times.
  • Lay on stomach with arms at sides. Pinch shoulder blades together as a first move and then raise arms off the ground. If that is too easy, add some light weights to increase resistance. 3x10.
Sonya also said that if I want to try running again, that I need to approach it in 30 minutes increments according to the following breakdown.
1 minute run, 4 minutes walk. Once that doesn't hurt..
2 minutes run, 3 minutes walk. Once that doesn't hurt..
3 minutes run, 2 minutes walk. Once that doesn't hurt..
4 minutes run, 1 minute walk. Once that doesn't hurt..
Gradually increase time and distance.

Clearly, I still have a ways to go.


Tuesday, January 24, 2012

The Diagnosis

I received a couple Orthopedist recommendations from friends and found that the earliest either could get me in was mid-February, more than a month away. Being impatient and in need of some idea as to what was going on, I found the first sports medicine Ortho listed by my insurance company. I got in within a few days of making the appointment. They took some X-Rays of my right knee (nothing structurally deficient) and diagnosed me with  Patellofemoral pain syndrome.

The Doctor, Mark Danziger, prescribed Physical Therapy and suggested investigating orthotics, supportive running shoes and strengthening of the quad since he suspects the injury is due to a muscular imbalance in that my VMO (inner quad) is relatively weak when compared to my vastic lateralis (outer quad). 

Later in the day, I utilized my complimentary 1/2 injury screening at Sports and Spinal to see Robert Gillanders. He performed some functional tests on me (step down with one leg, one leg balance-eyes closed, one leg squats) and some leg strength evaluations testing the hip, quad, hamstring and foot. He said that I didn't necessarily need to rule out Comrades already but would need a number of weeks of PT to get rid of the pain. He suggested I come back for further analysis and then the start of a regimen. He suspected the same muscle imbalance but also stated that it could be an issue of the whole system of my leg, from my hips to my feet. Unfortunately, S&S is not really covered by anyone's insurance and it would cost $165 for the first visit and $100 for each additional. And that's the cash price. This against a $25 Co-Pay for insurance-covered PT and my decision was made.

The following Day, 1/19, I had my first session with Sonya. She did some tests similar to Robert (step down, walking barefoot, strength, flexibility) and came to the same diagnosis. She also felt that my lateral collateral ligament (LCL) was loose because she was able to move my lower leg laterally. She gave me the following exercises to do, 2-3 times per day:
  • Laying leg raises. Lay on one side with body straight. Lift straightened leg up, hold 2-3 seconds and slowly lower. 3x10 reps; each leg.
  • Hamstring Stretch. Preferably with stretching band but 3 sets of 30 seconds each.
  • IT Band stretch. Preferable with stretching band but 3 sets of 30 seconds each.
I went back for my second session today, not feeling much better. Although I haven't been running, I have been bitten by the bug and feel the need to stay active so I've been doing some weight training and cycling and on Sunday, 1/22 I did an hour of water running. Possibly the most boring activity known to man.

In any event, today Sonya had me perform the same stretches and add another one to stretch my quads/hip flexor by laying on my back and letting one leg dangle and then pull that leg back with the stretching straps (3x30sec). She had me perform some strength exercises but wanted to wait until the next session to actually prescribe them. They included:
  • one leg step downs (3x10; each leg)
  • one leg multi-directional kicks using a resistance band (10x in each direction; each leg)
  • walking lunges with twist while holding 2x2lb dumbbells (3x down and back)
  • lateral walking with resistance band at ankles (3x)
  • and a clamshell exercise where the resistance band is between knees and legs hinge at the feet and hips (3x30sec; each leg). 
All exercises are meant to strengthen the legs and hips and possibly balance, too. I felt pain in my knee during the step downs and, to a lesser extent, during the lunges. I also felt some uncomfortable moments during the lateral walk.

I have my next session with her on Friday, 1/27 and will try and get an understanding of how long it should be before I start to see improvement. Tomorrow will be a month since the injury. This is very frustrating.

Monday, January 16, 2012

The Suck

I've been off from running for the better part of the last 3 weeks due to my knee issue.

Jan 4 & 6: Ran 3 miles each with minimal discomfort.
Jan 7: Biked 55 miles. Knee hurt after 15-20 miles and had to compensate over the rest of the distance
Jan 12: 1 hour on the elliptical, discomfort started after about 50 minutes
Jan 14: Attempted to run 7 miles but knee started hurting after .5 miles and ended up walking a fair amount, totaled 2 miles.

Based on the recommendation of a doctor friend, I've started doing leg extensions with a resistance band and stretching more but it seems to be having an adverse effect. After more self-diagnosis, I looked into treatment for runner's knee and have introduced some lightweight squats and lunges.

I have multiple sports medicine orthopedic appointments scheduled. Recommendations from a friend resulted in appointments with Dr. Johnson and Dr. Bennett but the earliest they could get me in was more than a month down the road (mid-Feb). Therefore, I am meeting with Dr. Danziger this Wednesday (1/18) followed by a complimentary meeting with Robert Gillanders at Sports and Spinal in DC. We'll see what they say but I may have to shut down the Comrades training or adjust the topic to injury recovery. FML.

Thursday, December 29, 2011

Better sooner rather than later?

Shit.

Since I messed up and didn't run on Sunday, I tried to get back on track by doing a long run on Monday, followed by 5 easy miles on Tuesday and the a speed workout at the Chagrin Falls HS track on Wednesday.  Big mistake.

It was a little above freezing with 1.5-2 inches of snow/slush on the track and I took 1.5 miles to warm-up.  Plan was to do a Hanson Speed Workout comprised of 4 reps of 3/4 mile @ 5k pace followed by 1/4 mile jog and cool down.  The warm-up was OK but I felt the tightness in my right knee.  However, after each interval, the pain in my right knee increased and finally, on the last interval I stopped for fear I might do some real damage.  In hindsight, I should have stopped earlier or not even started.

I walked a couple laps to try and cool-down and hope that the pain would subside but it only did so nominally. As I mentioned previously, I have been experiencing discomfort in my knee but it usually went away immediately after the run.  This time, the pain has persisted for more than a day now and hurts whenever I extend my right leg, step down, or perform a lifting maneuver.  It is a dull, general pain located near the bottom and slightly behind my knee cap.  It is not tender to touch.  I figure best case: patellar tendonitis, rest and recovery.  Worst case, a meniscus injury.  I'm going to rest it for a few days and see how it feels.

I've previously had issues with patellar tendonitis when I had a more pronounced heel strike so it makes sense that it would manifest itself again after changing my gait to compensate for my perception that the stress fracture was being re-activated. The knee pain only started after I started compensating in this manner so hopefully, I can let it heel a little bit, revert to my mid/forefoot strike and not get another stress fracture nor lose too much time from my training plan.

If it persists through tomorrow without improvement ,I'll make Ortho appointment.  Grrr...

Tuesday, December 27, 2011

Comrades Training Week 2&3 Recap

Total volume by week thus far:
Week 3 - 39.40 miles
Week 2 - 27.37 miles
Week 1 - 31.50 miles

A couple weeks ago I received the Sigma PC 25.10 Heart Rate Monitor via a sale on TheClymb.com.  I've had the Garmin 310XT since it first came out and was initially loving the device.  However, the honeymoon was over quickly due to consistent issues I've had getting an accurate heart rate. First, the Garmin softstrap HRM was showing my BPM frequently above 220, normal for a mouse perhaps but not a healthy human.  I switched out the Garmin strap for the Polar strap and readings improved but there will still regular issues.  For example, after 6 or so miles the reading would drop out to 60 BPM or provide no reading at all.  Not exactly helpful although the problem was only when I ran, readings on the bike have not been an issue.

The reason for the new focus on heart rate was an article I read where the author stated that by concentrating on maintaining a lower, fat-burning heart rate, he was able to condition his body to more readily utilize those higher-energy fat fuel sources.  In addition, although he was initially running more slowly in order to maintain a specific heart rate, over time his pace increased while his heart rate remained the same.  I wish I could find the article...  In any event, the Sigma PC 25.10 has been working great. Some spiked readings but overall, pretty consistent and much better than the Garmin.  Unfortunately, I have found myself wearing the Garmin on one wrist and the Sigma HRM along with a Christmas gift, the Nathan VitaBand on the other.  I'm certain I look half bionic man and half dork.

In any event, training runs have had a goal HR range and, for the most part, I've been able to stay within it; despite sometimes slowing to uncomfortable paces in order to keep things in line.  The pace I'm running sucks but I need to keep track of the goal, to keep my heart rate down and increase my pace over time.

Notable events of the past two weeks:
12/21 DC Tri Tack Workout: Ladder workout of intervals 3-3-4-5-4-3-3 with two minutes active recovery.  Established my Heart Rate Max at 195 BPM.

Christmas weekend "Back to Back."  You may notice it is not exactly a back to back and that is because I was hungover on Christmas Day.  Whoops.

Injuries/pains/etc.

  • For the past year plus I have been focusing on a more forefoot/midfoot ground strike for my running.  It had been going well but of late, but it feels like I may be aggravating the stress fracture I incurred last December.  Therefore, I've regressed to include more of a heel strike in my stride in order to prevent a re-injury despite sacrificing some efficiency.
  • Getting periodic feeling of shin splints in my right leg. Ebbs and flows during long runs.
  • Right foot arch discomfort. Not really pain, just feels like the tendons and connective tissue in my right foot are getting worked out.
  • Knee pain/discomfort.  Mostly in my right leg manifest as tightness and pronounced in both legs and pounding downhills (not unexpected).  
  • Aside from some expected soreness, none of the aforementioned issues are felt the day after (i.e. I felt them yesterday during my 14 mile run and not feeling any problems right now, the day after.)